@ Rachel: Haha, me too. But It's getting quite dusty where I keep my packages since I never use them.

@MissIndependent I'm on my last bottle of Black Star, I keep the bottles and packaging cause they look pretty

I've been using Forbidden rose for a while now, but I started to miss Black star so I just ordered a new bottle Even though Forbidden rose is my fave Black star has more 'attitude'

I have 2 black stars, I just had to have it and I bought it and then I got a new one for
christmas with a purse and the black stars creams. I just love the whole thing.
I don't use them so much I just have them
I think both fragrences are awsome so I can't say who I love best.
I love the acessories too , like the ring <3

Sorry bad english

Yay! I finally got "black star", I'm back from my travel to Germany and I bought this perfume and forbidden rose body-cream. I love them!^^

I've got it and it smells soooooooooooo goood its immense xxx

I have it.. It's a perfect perfume! =)

I have Black Star, but I would like to get Forbidden Rose! I think Black Star smells really nice and I CAN'T WAIT for her third fragrance either! Also I wear a necklace with the ring that comes along with it sometimes.

i have them both:)
and they smell realy great
i have them always whit me
and i school the toilets don't really smell great
so there always handy

I won one together with a hand signed TBDT on her german website
But I'm a boy, so I don't use it
So it's standing on my altar with all my CD s

I have a Black Star set (the one with a big bottle and a small one), and I LOVE them! I think the ring is SUPER DUPER CUTE, even though it hurts to wear it at times. I also LOVE the scent. I think Avril did a great job on it and Forbidden Rose! I hope she makes A LOT more!

I have loads of them all different sizes lol an Forbidden rose but i wear them both all the time they smell soo sweet an nicee xo

I have both and love them both, although I like a bit more than Black Star. I think this idea of Avril excellent as well as all others, it really is a great businesswoman. Just wish that were sold in all countries and not just some.

I've got black star and forbidden rose, I think that they're both fantastic!

I have both Black Star and Forbidden Rose and I must say that I'm so happy to have them!!! I can't choose which I prefer,'cause both are really great!I think the packaging of "Black Star" is better than the pack.for "Forbidden Rose",but when it comes to the scent,I really can't decide which one is better!Both are extraordinary,nice,fruitish lol And I like both rings as well!The ring that goes with Avril's first perfume is somehow more similar with Avril's way of dressing when she was younger....And the ring that you get with "FR" is more feminine...
I'm really in love with these two fragrances and now I can't wait for her new record and the third fragrance as well!